“Okay, you all know this song and you need to sing along, because we don’t know what fucking hours of music were going to play tonight we’re going to keep going, so you guys sing along with this one…” Jules De Martino providing an intro into one of The Ting Ting’s biggest hits, “That’s Not My Name”, just before Katie White throws down with the vocals and gets the audience into a frenzy at their sold out show at Harlow’s Restaurant and Nightclub in Sacramento on Saturday night. As mentioned in my review of their show for Popscene at Rickshaw Stop in San Francisco the night before, The Ting Tings haven’t passed through on a tour since supporting their sophomore album, Songs from Nowheresville, in 2012 (see my review of that show at The Fillmore). Their newly released third studio album, Super Critical, just came out late last year via their successful PledgeMusic campaign. Co-produced by original Duran Duran guitarist Andy Taylor, the album pivots them into a different direction, though with their trademark infectious and experimental sound and energy. I thought the show Friday night was amazing, and illustrated how the band puts a lot of thought and attention into creating a live show that refashions their music a bit with each outing, keeping it all fresh and exciting for the crowds they turn out… Somehow, the Sacramento show was even better, and will definitely be in my Top Ten shows of 2015 at the end of the year, and has set the bar high for all of the other shows I’ll be seeing in the next 11 months.

Who: The Ting Tings
Supporting: Kaneholler
Venue: Harlow’s Restaurant & Nightclub
Where: Sacramento, California
Promoter: Abstract Entertainment
When: January 24, 2015
Seating: General Admission (front row center; also photo pass)

As mentioned in my review of their show the night before, ever since seeing my first live show by The Ting Tings in 2012, I’ve become a huge fan of them and their work. I rated that 2012 show as one of my top ten favorite shows of that year, and named Sounds from Nowheresville as my very favorite (#1) album of the year and “Hit Me Down Sonny” as my favorite song of the year (also #1) in my 2012 Year in Review feature.

It has been pretty quiet on The Ting Tings front until they launched their PledgeMusic campaign last year, so I was thrilled to see that come about, and the release of “Wrong Club”, their first single off of Super Critical. Lucky for me (living in Northern California) that two of the handful of dates on this new tour were within driving range.

Funny enough, today I received my items from my participation in the PledgeMusic campaign – a set of stage used drumsticks and handwritten lyrics for “Hit Me Down Sonny”, each signed by Jules and Katie:

Harlow’s Restaurant & Nightclub is in downtown Sacramento… it is a great little venue and this show was 21 and up, but still sold out at capacity of 350 to 450 in the open floor capacity. Having been born in Sacramento and living in the nearby foothills about an hour away, I always try to support great shows like this in the area.

Since I saw The Ting Tings at Rickshaw Stop in San Francisco the prior night and then this show at Harlow’s right after, obviously a lot of the review below is going to be the same… (even the set list was the same) but there were definitely some differences as well. Overall, they were two distinct and different shows with different vibes and energy, and somehow I came away feeling like the Sacramento show was amped up to another level. I was not alone in this, as I ran across a couple I met last year at another concert, and right after the Sacramento show came to an end, they asked my friend Nori (who was also at the Popscene show the night before): “okay, which one was better?” Nori immediately said, “this one“, which was my feelings as well.

It’s always difficult to quantify this subjective views, but both bands seemed more energized, the performances smoother and more inspired… the lighting was more… illuminating. While Rickshaw Stop has a low stage, the stage at Harlow’s is even closer to the ground, so the artists feel that much closer. The crowd was awesome. I don’t know… it was just a touch more amazing than the incredible show at Popscene.

In any event, I’m so glad I went to both, as they were both awesome in their own unique ways – two different experiences.

Kaneholler

Members

Jon Foster
Chelsea Tyler

I’m a big advocate of encouraging people to turn out early at concerts to check out the supporting artist, and Kaneholler is a prime example.

I was unfamiliar with Kaneholler going into the Popscene show, but I was lucky enough to catch their pre-concert soundcheck both nights, so by the time they came on stage at Harlow’s, I’d heard a couple of their songs three times live, and also picked up their current EP on iTunes – Vol. 1 – EP and Vol. 2 – EP – in-between shows. So it was interesting hearing them “fresh” the first night and then being familiar with them going into Night #2.

I feel like they had a stronger connection with the audience at Harlow’s, and the sound was dialed in even better. As mentioned in my prior review, the duo is lucky to have both a fantastic sound and beautiful vocals.

Chelsea has a very unique voice that suits their sound and style perfectly. Now being familiar with their studio sound from their EPs, I am impressed at how good they are live (sounding even better, maybe). Many electronic-oriented artists don’t fare so well with live shows (they can often come across as sterile or stilted); Kaneholler is the opposite – they seem to love performing live so well, and are very natural performers.

Jon is a great match with her, as they bring such distinct masculine and feminine energy to the stage and play off of each other very well.

Their music is unique and super catchy – I’d not heard any of it prior to Night #1, and loved each performance of each song. With even limited exposure by the time Night #2 rolled around, it was even better. I will totally go out to see them again when the opportunity comes up. Highly recommended.

I spoke with them a little before both shows, and they are currently based out of Venice, CA.

Their next EP is due out soon, so keep an eye out for them and follow them on their official Facebook page for the latest news and updates…

Their set was really electric and song to song it was all really catchy and captivating. Definitely in the running for my favorite supporting artist in 2015 – they have set the bar high this early into the year.

Below are some photos of Kaneholler performing on stage – click any image to open an interactive lightbox with higher resolution versions of the images:

The Ting Tings

Members

Jules De Martino (drums, guitar, keyboards, vocals)
Katie White (vocals, guitar, bass drum, keyboards, cowbell)
Boix (touring member DJ on MIDI controllers and decks)

Much of these insights are “borrowed” from my review of the show the night before…

As I mentioned in my 2012 review, my first exposure to The Ting Tings was watching them perform live at Glastonbury in 2009 in a broadcast on Palladia, performing their hits “Shut Up And Let Me Go’ and ‘That’s Not My Name’, and I had three thoughts -1) I love them, 2) I need to collect all their music, and 3), I need to see them live.

The duo are a two piece band from England, and the aforementioned initial hits came off their debut album, We Started Nothing. The follow-up, 2012’s Sounds from Nowheresville, remains among my favorite albums of the 21st Century, which was a completely unexpected surprise for me (being just a casual fan of them prior to its release). To me, the album is – song by song, front to back – a masterpiece. Once I heard it, I went back to the first album and fell in love with it as well.

The original critical reception to that second album was mixed, with reviewers either loving it or not being too impressed by it, which to me in some rare cases indicates that it is a work ahead of its time, and people need time to catch up to the innovation and sound, much in the same way as the Beastie Boys’ second album, Paul’s Boutique, which is now considered by many to be one of the best albums (of any genre) of all time. And, for me, The Ting Tings are one of a handful of artists creating music that was what it was like for me hearing early Beastie Boys back in the day – just completely different and original and exciting. Not following a formula but being innovative and breaking out of rigid music genres and rules.

Sounds from Nowheresville was one of those rare albums that you just completely connect with from the start… you listen to the first song and hit the “back” button to hear it again, and it takes quite some time to make it through the entire album, because it is just that magnificent. And all of the songs feel as though they were born from different ideas; though there is a definite consistency throughout the work, there is no redundancy – each song is great as a stand alone, and no two sound alike. If you check out my 2012 Year in Review article, I do a detailed, song-by-song rundown of all of the tracks…

With their new album, Super Critical, the band cast out in a totally different direction, with the help of co-producer Andy Taylor. I’d read somewhere in the past that the duo seek to reinvent themselves with each album, and would even give their band a new name each time if such a thing were practical… The new work has more of a poppy/dance/club/disco sort of vibe that fits their catchy riffs and musical instincts quite brilliantly.

That first track, “Wrong Club”, is a great representation of the sound of the album as a whole, filled with layered, catchy hooks and riffs. There is more of a consistency throughout the album for Super Critical, compared with Sounds from Nowheresville, which was more of a compendium of wide-ranging experimentation. I love both approaches, but they are very different works. But a Ting Tings song is a Ting Tings song at heart (and there is no mistaking it), so in a live show, it all works brilliantly mixing things together from their different works and eras.

As has always been the case, their sound really crosses over many genres and styles of music, from indie/alternative to punk to dance/electronic to disco and funk, with a mosaic of bits of pieces from a number of disparate influences. The other great thing is that no one else sounds like them, nor do they really sound like anyone else. And they have been far ahead of the male-female pop duo that is increasingly popular today in newer acts.

I do absolutely love Super Critical. I am a huge fan of both funk and disco, and Super Critical is deeply infused with both, while still sounding unmistakably like The Ting Tings.

Super Critical still features loads of experimentation, but is more equal parts of a cohesive whole than Sounds from Nowheresville. It is also quite efficient, clocking in at just over half an hour (which actually encourages full, front to back listens).

Katie White’s vocals seem to get better and better with each new album, and Jules De Martino continues to be one of the more innovated artists in music today.

I think the two have really come into their own in knowing how to craft amazing songs, and hopefully they will continue to push the envelope (and do so with greater frequency) while making songs that are catchy and infectious. I rated their latest album and lead single in my Top Ten lists from 2014.

Getting to the concert, this tour different from the one in 2012, as they now have a third performer on stage between them – Boix (who recently did a remix of “Wrong Club”). I felt he added even more energy to the show and filled out the music, giving Jules and Katie the ability to focus more on their core onstage work. It also brought the more club-like direction of the new album out onto to the stage, and made for a really strong show.

If you’ve never seen them live, Katie takes a position stage left and Jules has his drum kit set up stage right.

Katie changes things up between mic on stand, roaming with mic, and playing a variety of guitars (or not), and is constantly showing the mic stand who is boss, tossing it around the stage.

Jules is behind his kit most of the time, though he does periodically play guitar, or record some guitar riffs to loop while he drums, as well as join in on some vocals.

Below is a photo of the set list from the show at Harlow’s on Saturday night:

Below is the set list…

Setlist:

Do It Again (Super Critical)
Shut Up and Let Me Go (We Started Nothing)
Hang It Up (Sounds from Nowheresville)
Great DJ (We Started Nothing)
Communication (Super Critical)
Give It Back (Sounds from Nowheresville)
Only Love (Super Critical)
Fruit Machine (We Started Nothing)
That’s Not My Name (We Started Nothing)

Encore:

Wrong Club (Super Critical)
Green Poison (We Started Nothing)
Hands (Sounds from Nowheresville)

I was super curious to see what they were going to play on this tour, given the new album and knowing the band themselves aren’t as big of a fan of Sounds from Nowheresville as I am (to say the least!). So in my synopsis of the set list above, I noted from which album each of the songs originated.

Of the twelve songs, five (nearly half) are from their first album, We Started Nothing, with only three from Sounds from Nowheresville and four from their latest, Super Critical.

The setlist from the show at Popscene was identical to the one at Harlow’s, so there was no change in the skeleton of the show, though the performances themselves were unique and it was just as fresh on Night #2.

Of course I was bummed that there wasn’t more from Sounds from Nowheresville (especially “Hit Me Down Sonny”, maybe my favorite of all of their songs), but I was not surprised. I think the set list makes a lot of sense and it all flowed really well, song to song, and each seemed to be redesigned for live play. I love the new songs from Super Critical, so it was a joy to hear them live.

The band is just so fun to watch, and they are a great live band. They sound great, they connect with the audience, and they obviously are having as much fun as everyone in the audience. In my opinion, they are one of the best artists to see live today, so I can’t recommend enough turning out for one of their rare live shows if you ever have an opportunity.

“Wrong Club” sounded amazing live, and is definitely one of their best songs in the catalog. I was lucky enough to hear it twice (once also in sound check) the first night and again at Harlow’s – it was fantastic each time.

Probably the most unique song of the night was the encore closer, the greatly reworked “Hands”. With pulsing/blinding strobe lights and a pumping beat, they played around with it for a while (with Jules off drums and beside Biox), I think it illustrated both their ingenuity as well as the versatility of their songs, which they have been known to rework in new and interesting ways.

Even seeing them play back-to-back shows… it actually made me want even more! I contemplated going down to L.A. for that show, but it took me a while to get through my photos from each show, so I ran out of Ting Tings time to hit up a third show!

Below are some photos of The Ting Tings performing on stage – click any image to open an interactive lightbox with higher resolution versions of the images:

Jason DeBord